Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife

52K Shares Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe This Amish Pumpkin Butter recipe is easy enough to make large batches and can, delicious enough to eat on gluten-free bread sandwiches all fall and winter, and unique enough to hand out as hostess gifts at fall parties! My husband is a sweet potato and winter squash lover in the extreme, and every year, he loves to plant a variety of new-to-him potatoes and squashes. This year, one of his new squashes was a small pie pumpkin variety called New England Pie, and we just started harvesting them about two weeks ago. For the record, I am NOT a sweet potato and winter squash lover. As I’m mostly Irish, I feel like my love for white potatoes is perfectly justified, and as I’m very, very white, despite also having Cherokee heritage, I’m not embarrassed at that I only love pumpkin if it’s heavily accompanied by pumpkin spice and well, not necessarily a latte, but definitely other ingredients that mask the texture of the pumpkin. #basicwhitegirltastebuds Wi...