Strategic Realignment: How Prabowo’s Visits To Turkey And Russia Will Transform Indonesian Foreign Policy – OpEd

The election of President-Elect Prabowo Subianto in Indonesia has significant importance in the country's political landscape and implications for its foreign policy. Due to his military background and strong nationalist stance, Prabowo's recent trips to Turkey and Russia have garnered significant attention, leading to speculation about a potential shift in Indonesia's diplomatic priorities. This essay analyzes the impact of these visits on Indonesian foreign policy, exploring their potential to reshape the country's strategic alliances and global influence.

Background

Indonesia's foreign policy has traditionally been characterized by its adherence to the principles of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) and the central role played by the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). This approach has allowed Indonesia to maintain a well-balanced position, avoiding entanglement in major power rivalries. Historically, Indonesia has maintained amicable relations with both Turkey and Russia, though these relationships have not always taken centre stage in its foreign policy agenda.

Objectives of the Visit 

President-elect Prabowo's visits to Turkey and Russia were driven by several strategic objectives. Firstly, there was a clear intention to strengthen bilateral relations. Both countries offer significant prospects for economic cooperation, defence collaboration, and partnerships. During the visit to Turkey, the discussions focused on trade agreements and technology partnerships, demonstrating a shared interest in expanding economic ties. In Russia, the agenda revolved around energy and natural resource partnerships, as well as strategic military cooperation. These visits also highlight Indonesia's aspirations to diversify its international alliances and reduce its reliance on conventional Western Allies.

Agreements and Discussions

During his visit to Turkey, Prabowo prioritized several key areas, with a particular emphasis on trade agreements to bolster bilateral trade volumes. Additionally, defence collaboration and technology were pivotal topics of discussion, highlighting the possibility of joint ventures in defence manufacturing and technological innovation. Turkey's thriving defence industry presents a valuable opportunity for Indonesia to enhance its military capabilities.

Discussions in Russia followed a similar comprehensive approach, emphasizing energy and natural resource partnerships that leverage Russia's expertise in these sectors. Military cooperation also took centre stage, encompassing discussions on joint military exercises, defence procurement, and strategic alignments. These discussions indicate a deepening of ties that could significantly bolster Indonesia's defence capabilities and strategic positioning.

Implications for Indonesian Foreign Policy

The visits to Turkey and Russia have significant implications for Indonesian foreign policy, particularly about the adoption of a multi-alignment strategy. Through the diversification of its partnerships, Indonesia aims to reduce its dependence on Western traditional allies and establish a more balanced and resilient foreign policy framework. This objective aligns with Prabowo's vision of an independent and robust Indonesia that is not reliant on any single power bloc.

Additionally, these visits serve to enhance Indonesia's influence by strengthening its connections with Turkey as a key player in the Islamic world and Russia as a major Eurasian power. As a result, Indonesia assumes a more influential role within the ASEAN region and beyond, reinforcing its leadership position and its capacity to shape regional dynamics. 

Economic benefits and defence capabilities are also crucial considerations in these partnerships. The establishment of closer ties with Turkey and Russia enables Indonesia to access new markets and advanced technologies, thereby promoting economic growth and fostering innovation. Furthermore, collaboration in the defence sector facilitates the acquisition of advanced military technologies, thereby reinforcing Indonesia's national security.

However, despite the opportunities presented, this strategic shift is not without challenges and criticisms. The task of balancing relations with the West will be complex, given the United States and the European Union's status as crucial partners for Indonesia. Any perceived deviation from these alliances risks straining diplomatic relations. The management of potential sanctions and diplomatic pressures from Western powers will necessitate careful navigation.

Additionally, domestic opposition and public opinion within Indonesia may be divided about the advantages of forging closer ties with Turkey and Russia. As such, it is imperative for Prabowo to effectively articulate a clear and persuasive vision to secure domestic support for his foreign policy initiatives.

To effectively address the aforementioned challenges, the implementation of several pertinent recommendations is essential. Primarily, Indonesia must adopt a balanced diplomatic approach that encompasses strengthening its ties with Turkey and Russia, while also engaging constructively with its Western allies. This approach should underscore the significance of common interests and shared values, to mitigate potential diplomatic tensions and ensure a diversified and resilient foreign policy.

Secondly, the fostering of transparency and dialogue domestically is of utmost importance. This can be achieved by actively engaging with political stakeholders and the general public, to forge a broad-based consensus for foreign policy initiatives. This inclusive process must incorporate the articulation of the economic and strategic benefits associated with these partnerships, as well as the addressing of any concerns or reservations regarding potential drawbacks. Ultimately, the leveraging of ASEAN as a platform for regional leadership is paramount. By positioning itself as a bridge between the East and the West, Indonesia can enhance its influence and assume a pivotal role in shaping regional and global dynamics.

In conclusion, the visits of President-Elect Prabowo to Turkey and Russia carry profound implications for Indonesian foreign policy. Through the adoption of a multi-alignment strategy, Indonesia endeavours to diversify its partnerships and decrease its reliance on traditional Western allies. These visits serve to augment Indonesia's influence and bolster its ties with Turkey and Russia, thereby positioning Indonesia as a more influential actor within ASEAN and beyond. Nevertheless, this strategic pivot is not exempt from challenges and criticisms. To navigate these hurdles, a balanced diplomatic approach, the fostering of transparency and dialogue domestically, and the leveraging of ASEAN as a platform for regional leadership are all crucial elements.

The opinions expressed in this article are the author's own.

References

• Emmers, Ralf. "Indonesia's Emerging Role in the Indo-Pacific: Determinants, Potential, and Constraints." Asian Politics & Policy 12, no. 1 (2020): 7-24.
• Sukma, Rizal. "Indonesia's Foreign Policy under Jokowi: Changes and Continuities." Journal of Southeast Asian Economies 33, no. 2 (2016): 174-182.
• Wicaksana, I. Gede Wahyu. "Indonesia-Russia Relations: From Diplomacy to Defense Cooperation." Journal of International Relations and Diplomacy 5, no. 3 (2017): 146-160.
• Erdogan, Meltem M. "Turkey's Foreign Policy in the Asia-Pacific: Opportunities and Challenges." The Journal of Turkish Weekly (2018).
• Prashanth Parameswaran. "Indonesia’s New Jokowi Administration: What Should We Expect?" The Diplomat, July 1, 2019.