Shoppers Say This $5 Glossy Lipstick Is a ‘Great Substitute for Clinique Black Honey'

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

There’s a reason why so many beauty fans are obsessed with Clinique’s Almost Lipstick Black Honey. It’s moisturizing, gives just that perfect amount of color, and lasts on lips for hours. But savvy shoppers have found a “great substitute” for the luxe lipstick, with some even saying it is better: the e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry.

This affordable pop of sultry lip color has a nourishing formula that feels like a mix between lipstick and lip balm, leaving lips soft and hydrated. Infused with meadowfoam seed oil and vitamin E, it’s no surprise one reviewer raves, “I love this product! It nourishes my lips and makes them very soft. It’s a bit like tinted lip balm and not too overly pigmented, but it adds soft color and a beautiful shine.”

The Black Cherry shade has become a fan favorite, with beauty lovers raving about its glossy, subtle finish. “Moisturizing, and received compliments almost right away,” says one happy user. It seems this lipstick is making quite the impression, with another fan sharing, “This is so sheer and light and feels so good on my lips. It feels kinda creamy when I apply it. It’s not sticky at all and has staying power.”

For those die-hard Clinique fans, the comparison is undeniable. “I have the Clinique Black Honey lipstick and wanted to try this e.l.f. substitute and I must say the Black Cherry is a great match. One coat is perfect,” reports a delighted customer. Another adds, “I bought it as a substitute for Clinique black honey. It’s beautiful!!! Not too dark and I love that it’s a subtle coat of color that gives you a bit more body to your vibe without being overbearing.”

So, why not give your beauty routine a refreshing twist? At just $5, the e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick offers a glossy, hydrating splash of color that could very well be the perfect addition to your beauty arsenal.

Before you go, check out our slideshow below: