Paul Rust’s Real-Life, Celebrity-Filled ‘Love’ Story

Paul Rust met the woman who would become his wife, Leslie Arfin, at a birthday party thrown by comedian Chelsea Peretti. “I found out later, Leslie was asking people there, ‘Who’s that guy, what’s his story?’” Paul said. “She asked Sarah Silverman, ‘Hey, do you know if that Paul Rust guy is Jewish?’ and I’m not, but Sarah said to Leslie, ‘If he’s not, his face should sue God.’”