2 delicious Girl Scout Cookie flavors are heading for retirement after 2025, which is rough

As the resident Girl Scout Cookie enthusiast here at For The Win, I was floored by the news on Tuesday morning.

People exclusively reported this: “Two popular flavors, Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yay!, will be available for the last time this year before being retired for the 2026 cookie season.”

Oh no! We’re talking about two cookies in my top-five of the best Girl Scout Cookies, ranked — Toast-Yay! came in at No. 5 and the S’mores flavor was No. 3.

No more S’mores! I say Toast-Boo to this decision as well. Sorry for the puns, but it’s how I’m coping. Definitely going to order these two this year.